Internet psychologist Graham Jones introduces the subject of free speech, relevant to whether 'undesirable' opinions should be repressed through use of 'no platform' tactics.
This raises some interesting questions: does the person or party who shouts loudest win? Do they need to maintain media domination through an unexpressed insecurity that a better perspective may come along?
Wednesday 10 June 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
▼
2009
(449)
-
▼
June
(39)
- Reading Joins Runaway Opposition to 3rd Runway
- Getting The Railways Back On Track
- The Different Sides Of The Prostitution Debate
- Representation Of The People In Action
- Housing Opposed All Along The Kennet Valley
- Pub Giant Accused of Anti-Enterprise Attitude
- Environmental Education
- Childcare Changes Starting To Take Effect - Part3
- Childcare Changes Starting To Take Effect - Part2
- Childcare Changes Starting To Take Effect - Part1
- Marketing Or Medicine?
- Expenses Redaction Causes Offense
- Berkshire MPs Expenses Exposed
- Shock At Jolly Angler Closure
- Going Nuclear, Or Not
- 'Cull-A-Councillor'
- Top Marks For Triple-H
- Election Special: Round-Up From the Blogosphere
- Tagged For Exhibit
- Two Wheels Are Better
- Labour Select Candidate For Reading West
- Recommended Reading List #28
- Residents Win Rebate On Tenant Tax
- A Shave Or A Spending Cut?
- Is It Even A Debate?
- Recommended Reading List #27
- Election Special: European Elections Local Results
- Election Special: Reading Bus Driver Shows Drive
- Election Special: European Elections SE England Re...
- Election Special: European Elections General Analysis
- Election Special: European Election General Results
- The State Of The Berkshire Blogosphere
- Top Of The Berkshire Blogs
- Expenses Scandal Hits Berkshire Councillors
- Election Special: Local By-Election Results
- It's Always Stay, Stay, Stay
- Recommended Reading List #26
- Parallels In Parking
- Housing Policy Politics
-
▼
June
(39)
- On The Eclectica Trail
- On The Election Trail
- Who Is Your Hardest Working Local Politician?
- The Expenses Scandal
- Berkshire Council Taxes
- Reading Budget 2010/11
- Reading Budget 2009/10
- Reading Civic Status
- Reading Festival
- Reading University in Transition
- Reading Buses
- Transport Matters
- Local Crime Issues
- Sport & Leisure Stories
- Children's Services in Reading
- Housing in Reading
- Local Media & Communications
- Weather Issues
- King's Meadow Campaign
- Bath Rd Reservoir
- Pincent's Hill & White Hart Meadow Campaigns
- Save Our Pubs!
- Heathrow Expansion
- AWE Aldermaston
- Berkshire Jobs
- BBC Berkshire
- ITV Local - Meridian
- Teletext Thames Valley
- BBC Radio Berkshire
- Heart Berkshire Radio
- Reading4u 87.9fm
- Reading 107fm
- Radio Bracknell Forest
- Asian Star 101.6fm
- Local Berkshire
- City Local - Reading
- Berkshire Life
- Reading Post
- Newbury.net
- NDS - South East
- Google News - Reading, Berkshire
- Topix News - Reading
- About My Area - Reading News
- Spark
- Reading Forum
Berkshire Campaign Links
- Action For Market Towns
- Amnesty Reading
- Berkshire Nature Conservation Forum
- Bring It Back
- Campaign Against Living Miserably
- Campaign Alliance For Lifelong Learning
- Campaign For The Reform Of Council Tax
- Econet Berkshire
- Greenham & Cookham Commons Commission
- Gurkha Justice
- Jubilee Debt Campaign
- Keep Trade Local
- Kennet Valley Ark
- Living With Fibromyalgia
- Loddon Valley Action Group
- National Playing Fields Association
- NO2ID
- RACE
- Re-Open The Jolly Anglers
- Reading Area Charities Together
- Reading CAMRA
- Reading Civic Society
- Reading Cycle Campaign
- Reading Friends of the Earth
- Reading Pride
- Reading Refugee Support Group
- Reading Single Homeless Project
- Reading Trade Justice Group
- Reading Voluntary Action Directory
- RISC
- Rising Tide
- Save Calcot Fields
- Save King's Meadow Baths
- Save Pincent's Hill
- Save Slough Town Hall
- Save The Bath Road Reservoir
- Save Windsor Fire Station
- SkyScreamers
- SOS Reading
- Stop Heathrow Expansion
- UK Missing Kids
- White Hart Meadow - Have Your Say
- Whiteknights Studio Trail
Reading List Politics
Political Information
- - Public Resources - -
- AboutMyVote - register to vote
- votewise.co.uk - compare the candidates
- TheyWorkForYou
- The Public Whip - MP voting records
- HearFromYourMP
- WriteToThem
- r8yourpolitician
- WhatDoTheyKnow - Freedom of Information requests
- iPetitions
- E-Petitions - No10 Downing St
- parliament.uk
- The Electoral Commission
- The Stationary Office
- The Hansard Society
- Political Studies Association
- Do Politics
- Get Elected
- The Straight Choice
- Democracy Club
- Be A Councillor
- I'm A Councillor
- Contact your councillor
- RBC Complaints Department
- Planning Portal
- Planning Alerts
- Report A Crime - Thames Valley Police
- Report Empty Homes
- FixMyStreet
- FillThatHole
- ClearThatTrail
- Scenic Or Not?
- The Best Of... Reading
- Touch Local - Reading
- info4local
- OnePlace - South East England
- UpMyStreet
- AboutYourArea
- GroupsNearYou
- ONS - Reading Statistics
- DirectGov
- NHS Direct
- NHS Choices
- Consumer Direct
- Connexions Direct
- jobcentre plus
- Tax Credits Helpline
- RecyclingNearYou
Help, Advice & Support
- Age Concern Berkshire
- Alcohol Help
- Berkshire Disability Information Network
- Berkshire Family Mediation
- Berkshire Lowland Search & Rescue
- Berkshire MS Therapy
- Berkshire NHS Drug & Alcohol Specialist Services
- Berkshire SAR Dogs
- Berkshire Women's Aid
- beYou
- Child Support Agency
- Childline
- Children's Information Centre
- Communicare
- Connexions Berkshire
- Daisy's Dream
- Divorce Aid
- Fatherhood Institute
- FRANK
- Gingerbread - single parents
- Heartbeats
- Help the Aged
- learndirect
- Life Story Theapeutic Centre - Psychological and Therapeutic Care
- links
- Living Reading
- National Debtline
- No5 - Youth Counselling & Info
- Parent Partnership Reading
- Princess Trust Carers Service (Berkshire)
- Readibus
- Reading & District Hospital Charity
- Reading Citizen's Advice Bureau
- Reading Community Welfare Rights Unit
- Reading Credit Union
- Reading Refugee Support Group
- Reading Samaritans
- Thames Valley Crimestoppers
- The Edge
- The Pension Service
- There4U - Berkshire
- Tilehurst Poor's
- Victim Support
- West Berkshire Buddies
"Reading List... is fantastic, it could help revolutinise politics in Reading"
Matt Blackall
"Prolific"
Matt Brady
"Irrelevant"
Adrian Windisch
"Bizarre"
Reading Geek Night
"A bloggers digest of the Berkshire blogosphere"
DMOZ
"An easily accessible collection of Berkshire's excellent blogs"
The Cookham Blogger
"An excellent digest of the thoughts of local bloggers"
Reading Guide
Matt Blackall
"Prolific"
Matt Brady
"Irrelevant"
Adrian Windisch
"Bizarre"
Reading Geek Night
"A bloggers digest of the Berkshire blogosphere"
DMOZ
"An easily accessible collection of Berkshire's excellent blogs"
The Cookham Blogger
"An excellent digest of the thoughts of local bloggers"
Reading Guide
Thanks for pointing us in the direction of this interesting article.
ReplyDeleteI actually wrote about the exact same subject with the same conclusions as Graham Jones around 10 months ago albeit a bit more political- it was for a book about student activism and my contribution was regarding student apathy and how to use it to your advantage. I'll get in touch with the author and see if i am allowed to stick it on my blog for all to see.
In terms of 'no platform', i am still stuck in the middle as whether i support it or not. On one shoulder the angel is saying to provide a platform that allows you to properly challenge and scrutinise (also means you can't be accussed of oppressing the voice of 'the majority'), on the other side, the devil is telling me that these views have no place in society and should not be given the time or place to be expressed. Before anyone claims that a 'no platform' is denying them freedom of speech consider two things: 1) article 30 of the UDHM; and 2) just because you don't provide a platform for those opinions does not mean they cannot go somewhere else and express them- so you are not repressing their freedom of speech. If you ban someone completely from expressing their views (i.e. no meetings, no website or blog, prision if you say anything) then you are.